One can crunch numbers and spout off about various SABRE-metric rankings of the best players in the league, but the bottom line is this: currently, Manny does more harm than good, and in the long run, his not being on the Red Sox roster will be a benefit.
The reasons, for anyone who follows baseball, are obvious and cliche: he's a distraction off the field, the media asks his teammates questions that only Ramirez can answer, he doesn't run out ground balls, he doesn't run hard out of the batters' box if he thinks he's hit a homerun, he grandstands, etc.
The "Manny Being Manny" stuff? That's actually not a problem. Talking on a cell phone between innings while hanging out in the Green Monster scoreboard is actually pretty funny. It doesn't affect the game or the play of the team, and it definitely counts toward having a "personality". And "personality" sells tickets and merchandise. Think about it: would Rich Garces have sold any t-shirts as a late inning reliever if he hadn't been a big fat guy nicknamed "El Guapo"? So personality is great, yes. I love it.
But Ramirez has taken his circus act in another direction altogether. If it is true that he intentionally took three straight pitches (all called strikes) in a late-inning pinch hit at-bat against the Yankees a couple of weeks ago in order to "get back" at the Red Sox and its owners, then he's clearly affecting his team's chances of winning. Twenty-three other players, plus coaches and trainers, dedicate their careers to one simple goal: winning ballgames. Ramirez, to prove some kind of point and take a measure of ill-advised "revenge" against the ownership, intentionally took action to hurt the team's chances to do so.
Along those lines, I read an article somewhere on Boston.com about the days off Ramirez has taken this season, whether via "faked injury" or otherwise. If I can dig up the link, I'll post it. The article said that Ramirez repeatedly took time out of the lineup on days when the opposing pitcher was a hard thrower. He skipped Edinson Volquez against the Reds, Justin Verlander against the Sox, Felix Hernandez against the Mariners (twice, if I remember correctly), and so on.
Again, when the Sox needed him most, he said "nope" and took a seat on the bench. Not helping his team win games.
That's not heart. That's not what the Red Sox is all about - at least, not the Sox I romanticize them being in my head.
I am not so naive to think that players aren't out there playing for their contracts. With free agency, every one of these guys is a mercenary. With rare exception, players are going to spend time in three or four different cities before their careers are over. The days of Cal Ripken and Tony Gwynn spending their entire playing careers in one city are in the rearview mirror and getting further away with every passing second (shh! Nobody tell Jason Varitek I said that!). Fine, I get it.
But at least respect your teammates and your fans. Play hard and at least run hard down the baseline if you're getting paid more in one game than most people make in an entire year. We buy the tickets, we buy the t-shirts, we buy the overpriced concessions at the ball park to pay guys like Ramirez, and what does he do? Shows us contempt.
He's got to go.
Curt Schilling put his career on the line against the Yankees in the famous bloody sock game. He understood. Like him or not, Schilling "gets it".
If Mike Lowell somehow was shot in the shoulder half-way through the first game of a double header, he'd want to go out and still play the second game.
Jason Varitek catches an inhuman number of games every year, sacrificing his body by wearing out his knees and lower back before he even turns 40. Why? Because he loves the game and respects it.
Manny? He claims the Sox are trying to make him look like a "bad guy", like they did with Nomar Garciaparra and Pedro Martinez. He claims the Sox are trying to run him out of town.
No, Manny. Dan Duquette tried to make Mo Vaughn look bad when he hired a private investigator to follow Vaughn to strip clubs. But when you push the team's traveling secretary to the ground because you didn't get as many comp tickets to a game as you wanted, you make yourself look bad.
As far as Nomar and Pedro go, go back to the Yankee game when the team was on the top step breathlessly awaiting every pitch, and Nomar was by himself sulking on the bench. Go back to the 2004 off-season when the Sox said that they'd love to bring Pedro back, but not for four years, and not for the money he was asking for given his shoulder issues (the Mets made the mistake of falling for it - go look at how much time he's spent on the DL since he signed with them).
We all have different perspectives on these issues - Manny was friends with those guys, and I've never met them personally. We're bound to disagree on some of the causes. But I find it funny that guys like Ramirez who leave other clubs as free agents all sign contracts and say to former teams, sorry ... it wasn't personal. It's just business. But when the team trades or doesn't re-sign a player's friends, somehow it's not "just business" to the player - the teams are "out to get" them.
Whatever.
Manny: Maybe, as you say, the Red Sox "don't deserve players" like you. But you definitely deserve playing for 13,000 apathetic fans in Miami.
In all sincerity, thanks for the two World Series championships you helped bring to Boston. It was fun while it lasted.
But, just as the Patriots made it to the Superbowl after Adam Vinitieri left to join the Colts, I think we'll get along just fine and will enjoy our next World Series with or without you, this year or some other.
You'll be missed, but not as much as you might think.